Wednesday, January 6, 2010

Komaza Shea Butter Hair Lotion

Okay ladies, I am a woman on a mission here! As you already know I am trying to find a natural moisturizing product to counter my dry, brittle ends. I know I could easily go out and get some HE LTR or many other suggested hair lotions I have heard about because they seem to be working absolute miracles for some ladies. But if you've already read my rant about hair products, then you know I am trying to find more natural products. It may hinder my progress, it may not, but I need to find out on my terms. So, on my hunt I came across this line called Komaza at Honey Fig.

Komaza has quite a few products to select from, but what caught my attention was the Shea Butter Lotion. Despite this company's claim to use all natural ingredients, there are a few that have chemical--mild versions of these chemical, but chemicals none the less. Again, I have no issue with using chemicals on the hair (I'm not a chemical hair Nazi ). My issue is don't tote your product as "all natural" with the price tag to match, and it's not. I digress.

Promises:
This Shea Butter Leave-In Conditioner contain no mineral oil or  petroleum which clog hair 
follicles causing slow hair growth. It contains vitamins and proteins needed to maintain 
healthy hair and promote growth. It also contains lecithin which absorbs moisture from the 
air and locks it into the hair shaft for 24 hour moisture protection without a heavy greasy 
build up. 

Ingredients:
Purified water, Dipalmitoylethyldimonium Chloride, Shea Butter,  Shea nut oil, Coconut Oil, 
Aloe Vera, Soybein oil, Nettles, HorsetailRosemary, Peppermint, Marshmallow,  
Behenetrimonium, Quaternium 87, Jojoba Protein, Silk Amino Acid, Cellulose,  
Panthenol,Vitamin A, C, & E,  Vitamin B3, B5, B6,  Jojoba oil Infused with Hibiscus, 
with Horsetail, Rosemary, Lavender, and Coltsfoot, Allantoin, Citric acid, Fragrance, 
Polysorbate 20, Potassium Sorbate, Cinnamom Cassia.

So after reviewing some of the ingredients on the back I decided to give this a try. The 
chemicals were minimal (e.g Polysorbate 20--- please read edits below made March 2010), 
so it's all good. Needless to say I found out later what Dipalmitoylethyldimonium 
Chloride was. It is a derivative of Palm Oil, which isn't harmful for the hair, but doesn't 
really benefit it or enhance its potential in any way. I do know that red palm oil is has 
several health benefits for the body--but this particular product has used a process 
version of red palm oil. Anyway, let's just say its a cheap filler because actually using 
more shea nut butter would be costly. But would it really? I mean I bought a tub of 
organic, unrefined shea butter, which was as big as the Komaza container for only $16--
a retail mark up. You can't tell me that if a company bought shea butter in bulk at wholesale, 
paired it with coconut oil--another beneficial, yet inexpensive oil that they couldn't still 
save overhead cost. It's just being plain cheap! You would think that at the price they are 
selling it for that it would contain more beneficial ingredients--geeze why did I buy this again?

My experience: 

Well let's just say when I opened the tester I wanted to eat this stuff straight out of the bottle! 
It smelled like absolute heaven. Ladies, your man will be all up in your frizzness with this stuff. 
I can still smell it in my hair and it's been three days now. Now, as for the other promises, it 
did leave my hair soft, so that was nice. It wasn't as moisturized as I would have liked and 
I found it a little greasy, so a LITTLE does go a long way. I am soooo heavy handed (I need 
to work on that), so it's hard for me to tell if it is actually greasy due to the palm oil (yeah 
I said it), or I am just putting too much of this stuff on my hair. Overall, I like it enough to 
keep using it until I find something that trumps this stuff. Unfortunately, because of the 
price and the main ingredient, I have to give it a Smiley!

ETA: (March 25,2010) I recently went to the the Komaza site and I was a little disappointed 
by what I saw. They recently made changes to their website, which included adding 
the complete list of their ingredients for their products namely the Shea Butter Lotion. Let's 
just say this is still not all "natural", which clears up a lot of questions I've had regarding the 
smell. The company now lists all of the ingredients on the products they sell, but my lotion 
surely did not have this information. I am disappointed by this largely because 1) they should 
be disclosing all of their ingredients and 2) rather than having one questionable ingredient at 
the bottom of the list (which indicates there is less of this substance in the product) there are 
three questionable ingredients, one items is much higher up on the list. It goes without 
saying I will not be repurchasing. It is way too expensive for what is actually in it. That's total 
BS in my opinion. It is is still a good product overall, but if you are like me hoping to use a 
100% natural products on your hair, then I would suggest you pass on this item.
            
HHG!

Smiley - Smiley = not worth the money, don't waste your time.

Smiley - Smiley = neither hit or miss; just okay

Smiley - Smiley = good product; really worth trying.

Smiley = amazing product!

5 comments:

  1. Love your attitude. Thank you for your review. However, I disagree. I found Komaza hair products to be some of the best out there. I was about to give up on my journey after a relaxer and BC, when I found these products (the Komaza Califia Care line) and I was able to breathe a sign of relief. All natural products do not allow room for preservatives which prevent bacterial growth (that would be disgusting) nor some of the best sufractants and emollients. In any case, even nature is partially about chemical reactions. And some plants are poisonous. So the nature vs. chemical debate has major faults.

    ReplyDelete
  2. @ Anonymous, thanks so much for taking the time to read and comment on the review. You are right, just because something is natural does not mean it is the best for our hair, nor does it mean it will create the desired results when combined with other ingredients. My argument wasn't really that natural ingredients are better than syntehtic ones (even though I think they are *smile*). My issue is when a company tries to promote a product as "all natural" and it is not. If something is made with synthetic products, but cost so much more just because it has a "drop" of shea butter I have to shake my head in protest. I might as well go out and pick up any old product off the shelf. At least it would be half the price. Oyim Handmade sell 100% natural hair products and they work just as well, and it is less expensive. That was my only issue with Komaza. Do the products do what they say they will do? From what I have tried, yes. Are they 100% natural? No.

    I am glad you found some Komaza products that work for you. I know just how hard this can be. Best of luck on your journey :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I had to do some more research *smile* I am wrong, Komaza and Oyin Handmade are on par with price. However, Oyin is still 100% natural.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks, I really like your post but if you are looking for an all natural products, why don't you try sheabeutimia products line. She uses 100% natural ingredients. The website is www.sheabeutimia.com.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for the info. I haven't heard of Shebeutimia. I will check out the link!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.